Puzzle Agent 2

In the game sequel, Tethers, a FBI agent, cannot let go of the unsolved Scoggins case and suspects a cover-up by the FBI. He decides to conduct an unofficial investigation and returns to Scoggins, leaving his colleague Jim Ingraham in charge of his files. Tethers stays at Valda's Inn and has a dream in which an astronaut visits him, leaving a note on the floor. When he wakes up, he finds the note, stating that "Isaac Davner does not exist" on one side and a list of names on the other side. Tethers discovers that the names belong to people who have mysteriously disappeared in Sasimy Woods over the years.

Tethers meets a local resident named Darryl Boutin, who reveals that his brother is one of the missing people. Tethers learns about Scoggins' folklore, particularly the Hidden People, from anthropologist Alfred Versteckt and his student Will Medlock. Tethers seeks access to the missing persons files from Sheriff Bahg but is denied. However, Glori Davner, who previously tried to kill Tethers, offers to distract Bahg in exchange for Tethers finding her husband, Isaac. Glori believes the Brotherhood of Scoggins is responsible for the disappearances and reveals that they had Isaac locked away in the eraser factory, believing he was "chosen."

Tethers successfully retrieves the missing persons files and meets puzzle enthusiast Melkorka Teterdottir, who posted the note under his door. She believes that Isaac's true identity is Ed Davis, a test pilot declared dead after his crash in Sasimy Woods. Korka believes Ed Davis is living in the woods as a serial killer responsible for the disappearances. She enlists Tethers' help in hunting him down and sends him to search the woods. Tethers encounters a member of the Brotherhood named Edvard but loses him and discovers the body of an astronaut before being spooked by the Hidden People.

Returning to Korka's house, Tethers finds her dismissing the Hidden People as an urban myth. He then interrogates Bjorn, the leader of the Brotherhood, who reveals that the Brotherhood members have also disappeared in the woods. Bjorn believes the Hidden People are angry about something nearby, possibly related to their "choosing" of Isaac. Bjorn directs Tethers to the cabin of Olav Welhaven, where Tethers discovers research connecting lunar eclipses to lunacy.

Returning to Korka with his findings, Tethers realizes she is obsessed with the "Kitimat Incident" involving a rumored Sasquatch discovery. Tethers seeks Alfred's help and shows him the research. Alfred suggests combining their findings to locate the Hidden People's home. Together, they venture into the woods, but Alfred disappears, and Tethers finds a campsite centered around a crashed lunar lander occupied by astronauts. Tethers spots the remains of a skier but is captured and sedated by the astronauts.

Tethers wakes up at Valda's Inn and learns that the FBI has discovered his findings. He confronts FBI Director Jennings, who warns him to back away from the case. Tethers refuses and discovers that the astronaut's body was an empty suit. Isaac reveals himself as Ed Davis, explaining his involvement in a secret mission to the Moon. The crashed lander disrupted the Hidden People's habitat, and they chose Isaac to destroy the Lunar Ray, a device that repelled them.

Tethers agrees to help Isaac and together they head to the lander. However, they are intercepted by the Men in Black. Tethers receives a call from Ingraham, who points out a melody in Olav's recording. Tethers realizes it was used to summon the Hidden People and returns to the cabin. The Hidden People enter, whispering to Tethers. He experiences an illusion where he agrees to help them destroy the Ray. When he snaps back, he finds himself at the lander in his underwear surrounded by agents.

Tethers sabotages the Ray, but it malfunctions, causing insanity. He escapes with the Ray and is unable to throw it into the lake due to the thick ice. The Sasquatch appears and breaks the ice, allowing the Ray to sink, ending its influence. Despite going against orders, Tethers is allowed to return to the FBI, while Ingraham is relocated for assisting him. Tethers receives a postcard from Isaac and Glori, who have reunited and are on vacation.