S5E2 · The Lie

Now in 1954, the survivors are attacked by the Others with flaming arrows, killing most of them. Juliet and Sawyer are cornered by military men but are saved when Locke intervenes. In 2007, Hurley takes Sayid to David Reyes. David takes Sayid to Jack, who revives him, while Hurley, the only Six member opposed to lying about the island, tells his mother the truth. Ben visits him and asks him to join the Six in returning to the island. Panicking, Hurley instead turns himself in to the police and falsely confesses to the murders. Ben goes to Eloise Hawking, who tells him she has found the island and gives him three days to return with Locke and the Six.