Plot summary
Catalina wants to help Earl on one of his items. She chooses #75: used a mail box as a trash can. Earl and Randy find some undelivered letters in the mailbox and try to return them to their senders. One of the letters was a love letter from a guy who was a personal trainer and fell in love with his co-worker at the gym, but when Earl finds the girl ( Jenny McCarthy ), he falls in love with her, although she seems to send mixed messages, forcing Catalina to bring in the guy to get Earl away from the girl. Meanwhile, Randy delivers a second letter to Joy and upon opening it, she discovers that Darnell is part of a witness protection program with his real name being Harry Monroe. Joy kicks Darnell out of their trailer and refuses to let him back in until he tells her the truth.
Credits
Adapted from Wikipedia contributors, My Name Is Earl season 2. HTML formatting and reference markers removed.