Plot summary
Peyton tries to get back to normal, but still has PTSD and runs out of school. Brooke's clothes are a hit at the local fashion show and Mouth is hit on by a model. But the party she invites him to clashes with the date he has made with Gigi. Deb lies to her doctor, then fakes prescriptions to support her addiction. Dan tells her to sign over the cafe to Karen. Mouth chooses Gigi over the model. Principal Turner finds out about Nick's affair, from Rachel. Brooke hopes to continue, but finds Nick cheating on her and she dumps him.
Peyton decides to stay with Lucas, still scared to be alone. Nathan is cornered by Daunte - he either pays Daunte 15K for the car or throws the Ravens game (not to lose, but win with a fewer than 10-point difference). Nathan is benched and Lucas has to fail baskets to save Nathan from Daunte's threats of hurting him. Later at the River Court, Lucas says he can never do it again. Nathan walks off as Lucas watches Daunte’s car pull away from the river court. This episode is named after a song by The Killers.
Credits
Adapted from Wikipedia contributors, One Tree Hill season 4. HTML formatting and reference markers removed.