5. The Sins of My Caretaker

A city employee notifies Fiona (Emmy Rossum) that the city will be doing sewer line work in the backyard, which will leave them without water for one day. However, Fiona realizes that the body of Aunt Ginger is still in the backyard; she orders Frank (William H. Macy) to dig her up, warning him he will go to prison if the body is found as he has cashed her checks.

With Molly (Madison Rothschild) and Mandy (Emma Greenwell) moving in with the Gallaghers, Lip (Jeremy Allen White) has become distant in their relationship, often declining her advances. During a visit, Lip yells at her, prompting her to leave the house; Ian (Cameron Monaghan) confronts Lip over his treatment of Mandy, knowing that it might be influenced by his relationship with Karen. Ian is also contacted by Lloyd (Harry Hamlin), who asks him for a favor; he wants him to rob his own house and retrieve his most personal belongings, with Ian keeping some of them. Ian asks Mickey (Noel Fisher) for help, and he gets his cousins to help in the robbery. Despite that, Mickey is shaken over Ian's relationship with Lloyd, especially when Ian says Lloyd is not afraid to kiss him.

Sheila (Joan Cusack) and Jody (Zach McGowan) welcome a nun as part of their hospice business. The nun uses a wheelchair and has chosen to take a vow of silence, allowing Sheila and Jody to continue their sexual encounters without incident. However, Sheila is shocked upon learning that the nun has written a blog named "The Sins of My Caretaker" that details her and Jody's sex life. Fed up with the nun, Sheila drops her off outside a church and throws her baggage at an incoming car. After failing to convince her co-workers over not giving in to the sexual advances of the boss, Fiona is bullied at work.

While at a public pool, Debbie (Emma Kenney) is humiliated when a few girls prank her over her body and she cries back home. After several unsuccessful attempts at getting pregnant, Veronica (Shanola Hampton) and Kevin (Steve Howey) consider finding potential surrogates; Veronica considers asking her mother Carol (Vanessa Bell Calloway).

After Frank fails to find the body, Fiona makes her siblings help in digging up the body. During this, Jimmy (Justin Chatwin) shows up, distracted over his father's sexuality. When Fiona downplays it, Jimmy calls her out for not supporting him when he always did. This causes Fiona to go on a meltdown, detailing all the problems in the family; upset, Jimmy walk away and turns to Estefania (Stephanie Fantauzzi) for emotional support. By night, the Gallaghers decide to continue the following day. Lip leaves an angry voicemail to Karen, and apologizes to Mandy for his actions.

Before the robbery, Mickey surprises Ian by kissing him on the lips. They manage to steal most of the items, but Candace (Julia Duffy) is alarmed by their presence and shoots them with a shotgun, hitting Mickey in the buttocks and forcing them to escape. They take him to the Gallagher household, just as two women are awaiting to meet them. Lloyd arrives and helps remove the bullet from Mickey. During this, Fiona finally finds Aunt Ginger's bones and Debbie tries to drown her bully at the public pool. As Fiona sees the chaos at home, the woman enters and is shocked by the events. She introduces herself as Brittany Sturgess (Keiko Agena), a CPS representative.